Custom Cakes for Any Occasion

Looking to make someone's birthday extra special? Need dessert for the company dinner? Celebrating a graduation? Surprising everyone with a gender reveal? Wildewood Pastry Shop specializes in custom cakes for any occasion. From writing and flowers, to scanned or drawn images, to edible dioramas, we can create the cake you need.

Click/tap on a category below for more information!

Sizes and Flavors

Standard custom cakes come in round or sheet cake varieties; we offer multiple sizes depending upon your serving needs. Round cakes have three layers of cake and two layers of filling; sheet cakes have two layers of cake with one layer of filling.

    Round Cake Sizes

  • 6" - (6-8 servings)
  • 8" - (8-12 servings)
  • 10" - (15-20 servings)
  • 12" - (25-35 servings)
  • 14" - (40-70 servings)
  • Sheet Cake Sizes

  • 1/4 Sheet (15-20 servings)
  • 1/2 Sheet (25-35 servings)
  • 3/4 Sheet (40-70 servings)
  • Full Sheet (80-100 servings)

Standard flavor choices are chocolate or vanilla (yellow) cake, with a choice of buttercream or mousse filling, and buttercream icing.

*Specialty flavors may require advance notice; please ask our store clerks for more information!

    Batter Options

  • Vanilla (Yellow)
  • Chocolate
  • Carrot*
  • Red Velvet*
  • Filling Options

  • Buttercream: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Raspberry, Lemon, Mocha
  • Mousse: Chocolate, Strawberry, Raspberry, Lemon, Mocha
  • Jam/Preserve: Cherry, Strawberry, Blueberry, Peach, Raspberry, Lemon
  • Other: Custard, Whipped Cream, Fudge, Cream Cheese (plain or with nuts and/or raisins), German Chocolate*
  • Icing Options**

  • Buttercream: Vanilla, Chocolate, or Color Icing (Vanilla BC)
  • Other: Whipped Cream, Fudge/Ganache (with or without chocolate shavings), Cream Cheese (plain or with nuts and/or raisins), German Chocolate, Fondant (simple color)

**Standard icing is buttercream; specialty options may require advance notice and/or limit decoration options!


To get a quote on a particular design, drop off a picture at the shop or send us an email with an image reference! Please note that quotes may not be immediate, and advance notice is required for all custom orders.

If you'd like to see some examples of custom cakes we've made, please take a look at our Flickr page! Please keep in mind that we can work from any design you show us -- not just our own. We're well equipped to realize your vision!

If you have toys or a topper that you would like us to use while decorating your cake, please provide these items sealed in their original packaging. Due to sanitary concerns, we cannot accept used or opened items, so please keep this in mind when ordering.

More Options

If you're looking for more complex decoration on your cake, don't forget to take a look at our additional custom cake categories:

We also offer single-tier anniversary size cakes (four layers of cake, three layers of filling) -- our store clerks can let you know what the right size is for your needs! If you're unsure of what type of cake you need, send us an email with your desired flavors and serving size, and we'll help you figure it out!